Donald J. Nicolls

Text size

Donald J. Nicolls

September 11, 1927 - June 06, 2018

Attorney Donald J. Nicolls, 90, of New Castle passed away the morning of Wednesday, June 6, 2018, at UPMC Jameson Hospital.
Born Sept. 11, 1927, in Poland, Ohio, he was a son of Carl E. and Ethel Mae (McCoy) Nicolls.
He was preceded in death on Aug. 3, 2016, by his beloved wife of 63 years, Beverly Jean (Nicodemus) Nicolls, whom he married March 22, 1953.
Don served his country in the Army from 1946 to 1947.
He earned his law degree from The Ohio State University, where he also played football on the 1945 team and continued to be an avid Ohio State sports fan throughout his life.
Attorney Nicolls practiced law for 65 years in New Castle with the law firm of Balph, Nicolls, Mitsos, Flannery and Clark until his retirement.
An active member of several organizations in the New Castle area, Don served on the New Castle Public Library board for more than 60 years from 1955 until the present, the City Rescue Mission board for 30 years and the Neshannock school board, the Neshannock Park Commission and the Camp LAMBEC Board.
Don loved to travel and enjoyed his frequent visits to the Grand Teton National Park.
Among his other interests, he liked to play volleyball at the YMCA and enjoyed photography, gardening, hiking and whitewater rafting. He looked forward to hosting his annual New Year's Eve party at his house, as well as the Nicolls' family reunion and Turkey Bowl Game held the day after Thanksgiving.
A member of Clen-Moore Presbyterian Church, Don served on the board of sessions, taught Sunday school and was active in the Tri-M Sunday school class.
He is survived by his two daughters, Beth Nicolls of Cleveland, Ohio, and Barbara Nicolls of New Castle; two sons, Bruce Nicolls (Cindy) of DuBois, Pennsylvania, and Dale Nicolls of Poland, Ohio; two sisters-in-law, Mary Nicolls of Columbus, Ohio, and Elece Ash of Lancaster, Ohio; and two grandchildren, Ian Nicolls of Denver, Colorado, and Hillary (Jonathan) Wildt of Chicago, Illinois.
In addition to his parents and his wife, he was preceded in death by two sisters, Betty (Donald) Grover and Ruth (John) Lewis; and three brothers, Bob (Mickey) Nicolls, Dave Nicolls and Gene (Ellen) Nicolls.
Visitation will be held from 5 to 8 p.m. Friday at the R. Cunningham Funeral Home and Crematory Inc., 2429 Wilmington Road, New Castle.
A funeral service will take place at 11 a.m. Saturday at the funeral home.
Burial will be in Poland (Ohio) Riverside Cemetery.
Memorial contributions may be made to the New Castle Public Library, 207 E. North St., New Castle, PA 16101; or Clen-Moore Presbyterian Church, 220 Clen-Moore Blvd., New Castle, PA 16105.
Online condolences may be offered to the family at
Published on June 12, 2018
Send flowers
in memory of Donald
See more

Obituary published in



Friday June 15, 2018

5:00 PM - 8:00 PM

R. Cunningham Funeral Home & Crematory, Inc.

2429 Wilmington Road, New Castle, PA, USA

Funeral service

Saturday June 16, 2018

11:00 AM

R. Cunningham Funeral Home & Crematory, Inc.

2429 Wilmington Road, New Castle, PA, USA


Print Guestbook

0 posts

Restore this Guestbook to share a memory or message of condolence of your own.